• Monday to Friday: 9am - 4pm
  • Saturday and Sunday: Closed


  • 1205 N. Walnut St.
    Bloomington, IN 47404


Maintenance Requests Pay Rent Apply Online


Until further notice, please contact us in the following manner. You may contact us by e-mail. If you do not know the email address of the person you need to contact, you may reach us by emailing info@hallmarkrentals.com. You may also contact us by calling 812-334-8819 9:00 a.m. to 4:00 p.m. Monday through Friday.

You may submit all maintenance requests online via this website for rentals and homeowner associations. As always, we will have our after-hours emergency system in place for true emergencies, only.

For payments, please place your checks through our drop slot or send via US Postal Service.
Thank you for your understanding as we all work together during this challenging time.

About Us

Over 78 Years of Property Management Experience

Why the pineapple?

Hallmark is known throughout the Bloomington community for its long-standing reputation for excellence and integrity. We are committed to elevating the standards of professionalism in the property management industry by bringing respect and ethical conduct to all business dealings and exhibiting outstanding customer service each and every day. Our goal is to live up to our promises, meet our clients’ expectations and develop a lasting partnership with the communities we serve.

Long known as a symbol of welcoming and hospitality, homeowners in Hawaii and across the Eastern Seaboard will leave a pineapple by their front door as a way of welcoming family and friends home. When you entrust your property needs to Hallmark, we guarantee you will be greeted with hospitality and high standards. For over 37 years, Hallmark has been growing its property management portfolio. We currently manage over 235 residential and commercial properties and 24 homeowner associations.

Welcome home.

A Legal Approach

Rooted in legal practice, we have all your bases covered. With 10 years of practiced experience in various aspects of rental and home ownership litigation, your property is safe in our hands.

We Bring Experience

Outlasting all Bloomington property management companies, we have been successfully growing our business for 37 years.

A Vision in Tech

Aware of the future, grounded in the past — that’s how we view technology at Hallmark. Implementing what is necessary for a modern, user-friendly experience, we keep our eyes on the client’s needs, meaning our technology is chosen only to enhance safety and improve business transactions, not create unnecessary losses.

We have Business Acuity

For 37 years, Hallmark has been growing its property management portfolio and increasing the number of home-owner associations who trust in our services. We currently manage over 360 residential and commercial properties with 24 homeowner associations.

This is Why You Can Trust Us

Simply put, at Hallmark, we provide a service you can trust. Our professionalism extends to everyone in our business, and our grounded approach to tech, expertise in law, and long-standing business acumen means that your property concerns will be met with quality services.

Rental Property Owners

If you are interested in our services, please hit the button below and fill out the form and we'll get back to you soon.

Contact Us

Homeowner Associations

If you are interested in our services, please hit the button below and fill out the form and we'll get back to you soon.

Contact Us